Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

scalac creates invalid class files, results in a java.lang.ClassFormatError at class-load time #7324

Closed
scabug opened this issue Apr 3, 2013 · 2 comments

Comments

@scabug
Copy link

scabug commented Apr 3, 2013

The scala compiler happily generates class files with more than 254 method arguments, which will cause a java.lang.ClassFormatError as soon as a JVM loads the class file:

object Foo extends App {
def foo(
_1: Int, _2: Int, _3: Int, _4: Int, _5: Int, _6: Int, _7: Int, _8: Int, _9: Int, _10: Int,
_11: Int, _12: Int, _13: Int, _14: Int, _15: Int, _16: Int, _17: Int, _18: Int, _19: Int, _20: Int,
_21: Int, _22: Int, _23: Int, _24: Int, _25: Int, _26: Int, _27: Int, _28: Int, _29: Int, _30: Int,
_31: Int, _32: Int, _33: Int, _34: Int, _35: Int, _36: Int, _37: Int, _38: Int, _39: Int, _40: Int,
_41: Int, _42: Int, _43: Int, _44: Int, _45: Int, _46: Int, _47: Int, _48: Int, _49: Int, _50: Int,
_51: Int, _52: Int, _53: Int, _54: Int, _55: Int, _56: Int, _57: Int, _58: Int, _59: Int, _60: Int,
_61: Int, _62: Int, _63: Int, _64: Int, _65: Int, _66: Int, _67: Int, _68: Int, _69: Int, _70: Int,
_71: Int, _72: Int, _73: Int, _74: Int, _75: Int, _76: Int, _77: Int, _78: Int, _79: Int, _80: Int,
_81: Int, _82: Int, _83: Int, _84: Int, _85: Int, _86: Int, _87: Int, _88: Int, _89: Int, _90: Int,
_91: Int, _92: Int, _93: Int, _94: Int, _95: Int, _96: Int, _97: Int, _98: Int, _99: Int, _100: Int,
_101: Int, _102: Int, _103: Int, _104: Int, _105: Int, _106: Int, _107: Int, _108: Int, _109: Int, _110: Int,
_111: Int, _112: Int, _113: Int, _114: Int, _115: Int, _116: Int, _117: Int, _118: Int, _119: Int, _120: Int,
_121: Int, _122: Int, _123: Int, _124: Int, _125: Int, _126: Int, _127: Int, _128: Int, _129: Int, _130: Int,
_131: Int, _132: Int, _133: Int, _134: Int, _135: Int, _136: Int, _137: Int, _138: Int, _139: Int, _140: Int,
_141: Int, _142: Int, _143: Int, _144: Int, _145: Int, _146: Int, _147: Int, _148: Int, _149: Int, _150: Int,
_151: Int, _152: Int, _153: Int, _154: Int, _155: Int, _156: Int, _157: Int, _158: Int, _159: Int, _160: Int,
_161: Int, _162: Int, _163: Int, _164: Int, _165: Int, _166: Int, _167: Int, _168: Int, _169: Int, _170: Int,
_171: Int, _172: Int, _173: Int, _174: Int, _175: Int, _176: Int, _177: Int, _178: Int, _179: Int, _180: Int,
_181: Int, _182: Int, _183: Int, _184: Int, _185: Int, _186: Int, _187: Int, _188: Int, _189: Int, _190: Int,
_191: Int, _192: Int, _193: Int, _194: Int, _195: Int, _196: Int, _197: Int, _198: Int, _199: Int, _200: Int,
_201: Int, _202: Int, _203: Int, _204: Int, _205: Int, _206: Int, _207: Int, _208: Int, _209: Int, _210: Int,
_211: Int, _212: Int, _213: Int, _214: Int, _215: Int, _216: Int, _217: Int, _218: Int, _219: Int, _220: Int,
_221: Int, _222: Int, _223: Int, _224: Int, _225: Int, _226: Int, _227: Int, _228: Int, _229: Int, _230: Int,
_231: Int, _232: Int, _233: Int, _234: Int, _235: Int, _236: Int, _237: Int, _238: Int, _239: Int, _240: Int,
_241: Int, _242: Int, _243: Int, _244: Int, _245: Int, _246: Int, _247: Int, _248: Int, _249: Int, _250: Int,
_251: Int, _252: Int, _253: Int, _254: Int, _255: Int
) = ???
}
java.lang.ClassFormatError: Too many arguments in method signature in class file Foo$
	at java.lang.ClassLoader.defineClass1(Native Method)
	at java.lang.ClassLoader.defineClass(ClassLoader.java:787)
	at scala.tools.nsc.util.AbstractFileClassLoader.findClass(AbstractFileClassLoader.scala:87)
	at java.lang.ClassLoader.loadClass(ClassLoader.java:423)
	at java.lang.ClassLoader.loadClass(ClassLoader.java:356)
	at java.lang.Class.getDeclaredMethods0(Native Method)
	at java.lang.Class.privateGetDeclaredMethods(Class.java:2451)
	at java.lang.Class.privateGetPublicMethods(Class.java:2571)
	at java.lang.Class.getMethods(Class.java:1429)
object Bar extends App
class Bar(
_1: Int, _2: Int, _3: Int, _4: Int, _5: Int, _6: Int, _7: Int, _8: Int, _9: Int, _10: Int,
_11: Int, _12: Int, _13: Int, _14: Int, _15: Int, _16: Int, _17: Int, _18: Int, _19: Int, _20: Int,
_21: Int, _22: Int, _23: Int, _24: Int, _25: Int, _26: Int, _27: Int, _28: Int, _29: Int, _30: Int,
_31: Int, _32: Int, _33: Int, _34: Int, _35: Int, _36: Int, _37: Int, _38: Int, _39: Int, _40: Int,
_41: Int, _42: Int, _43: Int, _44: Int, _45: Int, _46: Int, _47: Int, _48: Int, _49: Int, _50: Int,
_51: Int, _52: Int, _53: Int, _54: Int, _55: Int, _56: Int, _57: Int, _58: Int, _59: Int, _60: Int,
_61: Int, _62: Int, _63: Int, _64: Int, _65: Int, _66: Int, _67: Int, _68: Int, _69: Int, _70: Int,
_71: Int, _72: Int, _73: Int, _74: Int, _75: Int, _76: Int, _77: Int, _78: Int, _79: Int, _80: Int,
_81: Int, _82: Int, _83: Int, _84: Int, _85: Int, _86: Int, _87: Int, _88: Int, _89: Int, _90: Int,
_91: Int, _92: Int, _93: Int, _94: Int, _95: Int, _96: Int, _97: Int, _98: Int, _99: Int, _100: Int,
_101: Int, _102: Int, _103: Int, _104: Int, _105: Int, _106: Int, _107: Int, _108: Int, _109: Int, _110: Int,
_111: Int, _112: Int, _113: Int, _114: Int, _115: Int, _116: Int, _117: Int, _118: Int, _119: Int, _120: Int,
_121: Int, _122: Int, _123: Int, _124: Int, _125: Int, _126: Int, _127: Int, _128: Int, _129: Int, _130: Int,
_131: Int, _132: Int, _133: Int, _134: Int, _135: Int, _136: Int, _137: Int, _138: Int, _139: Int, _140: Int,
_141: Int, _142: Int, _143: Int, _144: Int, _145: Int, _146: Int, _147: Int, _148: Int, _149: Int, _150: Int,
_151: Int, _152: Int, _153: Int, _154: Int, _155: Int, _156: Int, _157: Int, _158: Int, _159: Int, _160: Int,
_161: Int, _162: Int, _163: Int, _164: Int, _165: Int, _166: Int, _167: Int, _168: Int, _169: Int, _170: Int,
_171: Int, _172: Int, _173: Int, _174: Int, _175: Int, _176: Int, _177: Int, _178: Int, _179: Int, _180: Int,
_181: Int, _182: Int, _183: Int, _184: Int, _185: Int, _186: Int, _187: Int, _188: Int, _189: Int, _190: Int,
_191: Int, _192: Int, _193: Int, _194: Int, _195: Int, _196: Int, _197: Int, _198: Int, _199: Int, _200: Int,
_201: Int, _202: Int, _203: Int, _204: Int, _205: Int, _206: Int, _207: Int, _208: Int, _209: Int, _210: Int,
_211: Int, _212: Int, _213: Int, _214: Int, _215: Int, _216: Int, _217: Int, _218: Int, _219: Int, _220: Int,
_221: Int, _222: Int, _223: Int, _224: Int, _225: Int, _226: Int, _227: Int, _228: Int, _229: Int, _230: Int,
_231: Int, _232: Int, _233: Int, _234: Int, _235: Int, _236: Int, _237: Int, _238: Int, _239: Int, _240: Int,
_241: Int, _242: Int, _243: Int, _244: Int, _245: Int, _246: Int, _247: Int, _248: Int, _249: Int, _250: Int,
_251: Int, _252: Int, _253: Int, _254: Int, _255: Int
)
java.lang.ClassFormatError: Too many arguments in method signature in class file Bar
	at java.lang.ClassLoader.defineClass1(Native Method)
	at java.lang.ClassLoader.defineClass(ClassLoader.java:787)
	at scala.tools.nsc.util.AbstractFileClassLoader.findClass(AbstractFileClassLoader.scala:87)
	at java.lang.ClassLoader.loadClass(ClassLoader.java:423)
	at java.lang.ClassLoader.loadClass(ClassLoader.java:356)

Both examples should be rejected by the compiler.

@scabug
Copy link
Author

scabug commented Apr 3, 2013

Imported From: https://issues.scala-lang.org/browse/SI-7324?orig=1
Reporter: @soc
Affected Versions: 2.10.1, 2.11.0-M2

@scabug
Copy link
Author

scabug commented Apr 21, 2013

@paulp said:
scala/scala#2426

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants